ACMi-21
Media partner

Site stats: December traffic (record) | Patch: Town updates | Cambridge Day: News >> 

Your View (site blog, not mine personally)

Your View is the place for opinion at YourArlington.com. It is the site's only blog. Please submit your opinions to be considered for publication on this site. The best opinions are those supported by facts. You cannot expect to be published if your views lack factual support or if you make personal attacks. For your views to be published, your full, real name is required.
3 minutes reading time (544 words)

Reasons to keep 21 precincts for Town Meeting

The following fact-based viewpoint about proposed precinct changes in Arlington was submitted by Mark Rosenthal, a Precinct 14 resident. It is a revised version of his views from those appearing earlier on social media.

Reprecincting logo

Here are some of the reasons that I believe it would be a bad idea to reduce the number of Town Meeting Precincts from 21 to 16.1.

1. Arlington's Reprecincting Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) document makes much of the supposed financial savings that would result from reducing the number of precincts, but the amount of savings would actually be negligible. 

I phoned the town cerk to ask the cost of staffing each polling place on Election Day and was told that on that day, each precinct is staffed by six volunteers: four inspectors compensated at $170 for the day, one warden compensated at $225 for the day and one clerk compensated at $200 for the day. 

I was also told that the training for each volunteer takes approximately two hours, and is compensated at an hourly rate approximately one-12th of the Election Day compensation.  This works out to a cost per precinct of approximately $1,289.16. 

Thus, the savings from reducing the number of precincts from 21 to 16 is about $6,445.80 per election.

 In a town whose 2022 budget is in excess of $190 million, this amounts to 0.0034 percent of the annual budget, which is the equivalent of a person with an annual salary of $100,000 worrying about saving a mere $3.40!  So the amount saved by reducing the number of precincts is negligible.

2. Reducing the number of precincts runs directly counter to the Reprecincting Working Group's claims to be interested in increasing diversity, because it would increase lock-in for incumbents.

New candidates don't have name recognition, so they need to spend money to mail campaign literature, and with 16 larger precincts each candidate would have to spend about one-third more on mailings than in a 21-precinct system. Meanwhile, many incumbents get reelected to Town Meeting just on the strength of their name recognition, without doing mailings.

3. The FAQ argues that having fewer precincts will enable the town to respond more nimbly in adapting procedures in response to changes in election laws.  But the only anticipated change I'm aware of is not to election laws, but rather to the boundaries of congressional districts, which will necessitate adjustments to precinct boundaries when the new district boundaries are finally announced. 

After this year, this won't happen again for a decade. The precinct boundaries will need to be adjusted so as not to cross congressional districts regardless of whether we have 16 or 21 precincts.

Having fewer precincts doesn't make it any easier to redraw the precinct boundaries.  If anything, having more precincts would provide more flexibility in this regard.

4. The FAQ argues that with each polling location hosting two precincts, every precinct will have a more uniform voting experience.  This is a red herring. 

No voter I know of cares whether or not their polling location hosts one or two precincts.


Sept. 29, 2021: Fair or foul? A closer look at reprecincting options; town updates maps  

 

Sept. 26, 2021: What do you think about plans for precinct changes?

 


This viewpoint was published Tuesday, Oct. 12, 2021.

Letters: Emailing Advocate? Copy it here
ADUs part 3: A Family Story
 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Monday, 24 January 2022
If you'd like to register, please fill in the username, password and name fields.

Captcha Image

By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://www.yourarlington.com/

Your Businesses

Latest Comments

Don Seltzer For town housing, move beyond critique to solutions
24 January 2022
Grant, up until your final snide comment I am in general agreement with you. Impact of new housing upon public school enrollment is highly dependent on the type of housing. And that is why I fault t...
Grant Cook For town housing, move beyond critique to solutions
24 January 2022
I will point out Don that your own math around school enrollment that really don't justify the hyperbole of claiming that a new elementary is around the corner. Your calculation around housing units ...
Steve Berczuk For town housing, move beyond critique to solutions
23 January 2022
Also: I was reacting to the comment that I made an incorrect "accusation" which I take seriously. Looking at the two articles again, my "facts straight" comment was about this sentence "This draft rep...

Housing Authority

Your People

Rachel N. Albert

Food Link's new exec outlines goals, offers personal insights

Rachel N. Albert, Food Link executive director For Rachel N. Albert, the roots of social consciousness run deep. When she was about 5, she accompanied her mom who has distributing pamphlets about the environmental impact of nuclear energy. "My parents were early advocates of organic farming and…
Sue and Jeff Thompson

A diagnosis of ALS leaves couple in need

Sue and Jeff Thompson, formerly of Firefly Moon, keep the faith. UPDATED Dec. 18: Every evening, Sue Thompson and her husband, Jeff, drink a toast. Whether or not they have a glass of wine, it’s to give thanks that they have been given another day despite challenges that have left them in…
Evvie Jagoda.

Town resident voted out among castaways on new 'Survivor'

Evvie Jagoda seeks ties that bind. UPDATED Nov. 24: The Covid-delayed season of CBS-TV's "Survivor" launched Sept. 22 with 18 new castaways, including Arlington resident Evvie Jagoda. She hung in with spunk until episode 8 broadcast Nov. 17. Read one summary >> And another >> And last: Evvie…






FACEBOOK BOX: To see all images, click the PHOTOS link just below

 




Support YourArlington

RSM, 2021-22
Paid support

Your Arts

Supporter

Development

Your Police, Fire