Media partner

Site stats: April traffic | Patch: Town updates | Cambridge Day: News >> 

Your View (site blog, not mine personally)

Your View is the place for opinion at YourArlington.com. It is the site's only blog. Please submit your opinions to be considered for publication on this site. The best opinions are those supported by facts. You cannot expect to be published if your views lack factual support or if you make personal attacks. For your views to be published, your full, real name is required.
4 minutes reading time (746 words)

Support for Schlichtman -- and the value of data

Steve Berczuk of Teel Street submitted these comments supporting Paul Schlichtman, a candidate for reelection to the School Committee, and addressing the discussion of racial data after the ACMi debate. 

Paul Schlichtman, School Committee candidate, 2020 photoSchlichtman

The School Committee race in Arlington has taken a counterproductive turn.

The School Committee faces many challenges, including the need to improve education for everyone, hire a new superintendent and enable APS to function as effectively as possible in the Covid-19 pandemic era. And yet a large amount of effort has been spent on one sentence taken out of context.

Paul Schlichtman -- a thoughtful, experienced educator, administrator and School Committee member -- wrote a letter, and applied his analytical skills and experience as an educator and education administrator to rebut what he believed to be an inaccurate characterization of statistics by Lynette Martyn during the April 17 Arlington School Committee debate.  Candidate Martyn and some of her supporters have responded to his analysis not by addressing the data but using a line taken out of context to misrepresent Schlichtman’s position on achievement gaps in the Arlington Public Schools (APS). This is shocking and disappointing.

Schlichtman’s letter opened:

“… The “widespread disparity gaps” that are the centerpiece of Ms. Martyn’s campaign simply don’t exist. We are not shortchanging “thousands of students” in the Arlington Public Schools, and these accusations are defamatory and particularly hurtful to the dedicated and caring educators working in these schools.”

Schlichtman presented detailed numbers explaining how “We are not shortchanging 'thousands of students' in the Arlington Public Schools” -- the specific aspect of Martyn’s claims that had concerned him in the debate. He walked readers through his analysis, making it possible for them to evaluate his argument. 

From Schlichtman’s almost 1,000-word letter filled with facts and figures, Martyn focused her response on his one phrase (“widespread disparity gaps ... don’t exist”) and has yet to respond with a comparable analysis that could help the voters understand why her own claims were correct. Similarly, published letters to Your Arlington and The Advocate endorsing Martyn and challenging the Schlichtman essay also take the same phrase out of context and, generally, do not disclose specific objections to his critique, with its underlying numbers indicating that APS does not shortchange “thousands of students.”

Schlichtman has repeatedly acknowledged (including in his ACMi candidate interview) the disparities in education and other challenges that some students face, because of racial and cultural biases, SPED funding levels and other constraints. Still, the major objection raised to Schlichtman’s candidacy by Martyn and some supporters continues to be that he denies the existence of such disparities.

There are many ways to identify and describe problems. Some problems can be quantified (e.g., based on 2019 data that several letter writers, including Schlichtman, are using to summarize potential issues, such as numbers of students disciplined). Personal stories, anecdotes and other observations can live alongside the more quantifiable data to help us identify challenges that need attention. (As an example of the latter, Schlichtman’s letter discussed the potential contribution of late transfer into APS on student dropout.) Meaningful analysis and full consideration of the underlying evidence are how we can understand the true scope, and nature, of disparities in APS.

I hope that in the home stretch of the election the candidates can focus the debate on how best to understand the present state of APS and the scope and nature of disparities, rather than expending more energy on an out-of-context phrase, that triggers “blanket outrage” and gives the erroneous impression that one candidate does not care about ensuring that all APS students receive the support they need to succeed. Schlichtman’s words during this campaign, and his actions as a School Committee member over 18 years, clearly show that he does care and is not blind to the existence of disparities.

I believe that Paul Schlichtman with his extensive experience as an educator, education administrator and education policy official who understands data analysis will help the School Committee to address the challenges APS will be facing.

Rather than focusing on words out of context, let’s talk about how, after the campaign is over, each candidate will apply their different perspectives and approaches to collaborate with the others on the seven-member School Committee to find the right solutions for our community.


This commentary was published Thursday, May 21, 2020.

Comments about this column are welcome. Make them at the window below and be sure to include your full name, a site requirement.

Town of Arlington to LGBTQIA+ students: You belong
 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Monday, 23 May 2022
If you'd like to register, please fill in the username, password and name fields.

Captcha Image

By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://www.yourarlington.com/

YOUR VIEW: Opinions: MBTA, Roe, Alewife, racism, film, Ukraine, letters, poetry

Your Businesses

Latest comments

John Yurewicz Alewife Brook sewage campaign: Support from Ellen Mass
05 March 2022
The Thorndike Place apartment and pavement construction will re-direct natural underground aquifers ...
Bob Sprague Letters: Emailing Advocate? Copy it here. Roe v. Wade?
17 January 2022
Let the public know with a letter to the editor. For details, see https://www.yourarlington.com/easy...

Housing Authority

Your People

Wally greets Marianne Comeau at Del's.

Longtime resident recalls how Red Sox gave her hits she needed

Wally greets Marianne Comeau at Del's. UPDATED May 21: You may have seen Marianne Comeau doling out paddles for canoes at Spy Pond in summers past. Or at the Ed Burns rec center working with kids. Or simply jogging around town, something she has done since 1979. The affable friend to police…
Lt. Dan Kelly

Retired Arlington police lieutenant dies at 58

Lt. Dan Kelly Lt. Dan Kelly, a retired member of the Arlington Police Department, died Tuesday, May 3, after fighting cancer for several years, Chief Julie Flaherty said in a report by YourArlington partner Patch. Kelly, 58, served 32 years as a decorated member of the Arlington Police Department.…
Sulinha Boucher, 2022

Younger than 5: 4th album for Arlington musician

Sulinha Boucher “We Should Be Kind." Listen to it here >> Sulinha Boucher, an Arlington musician for 30 years who is originally from Brazil, has recorded her fourth album for children, “We Should Be Kind." Perhaps you have heard her at the Robbins and Fox libraries, where she has performed for the…






FACEBOOK BOX: To see all images, click the PHOTOS link just below

 



Support YourArlington

An informed Arlington
keeps democracy alive
:
Why we are your news source >>

Donate Button

YourArlington is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit.

Your contributions are tax-deductible.

Wednesday Newsletter

Your Arts

Your Police, Fire

Development

Site Partners

Patch header

Arlington Patch

Arlington Patch has been reporting about the town since 2010. The national site with local outlets…